SEO and Etsy Ads for Beginners: Why You Shouldn't Run Ads

Home » ENGLISH » Small Biz Essentials » Promote Your Brand » SEO and Etsy Ads for Beginners: Why You Shouldn’t Run Ads

Master SEO and Etsy Ads as a beginner! Learn when you should run ads and when you shouldn’t. Includes the checklist to improve SEO.

When I first started exploring Etsy ads, I didn’t realize how crucial it was to build a strong SEO foundation before spending a single dollar on advertising. I was desperate to get my products seen. Honestly, after trying both approaches myself, it made me realize that patience with SEO before ads leads to significantly better results. Let me share what I’ve learned.

Why You Should Hold Off on Etsy Ads at the Start

I was just trying to get more visibility when I first considered ads, but I quickly learned this approach could backfire. You don’t need immediate ad exposure, you need solid SEO fundamentals first.

What really surprised me was discovering that Etsy ads simply amplify what’s already working (or not working). Think of it this way. If your listings have poor SEO, throwing money at ads is like using a megaphone to announce a party nobody wanted to attend in the first place.

In essence, without natural engagement like favorites, carts, or early interactions, paid ads often become extremely expensive with minimal return. On top of that, the lack of customer reviews makes it significantly harder to convert ad-driven traffic into actual sales.

The thing we call “successful advertising” is just good SEO being amplified. It’s kind of like trying to use expensive fertilizer on a plant that hasn’t been properly watered or placed in sunlight. You’re wasting resources on something that needs the basics first.

How Etsy SEO Actually Works

I firmly believe that understanding Etsy’s SEO mechanics is absolutely essential before spending your hard-earned money on advertising.

Lately, I’ve been obsessing on keyword research and it’s been transforming how I create listings every day. The way I approach this is to use Etsy’s own search bar to identify what potential customers are genuinely searching for. (Tools like Marmalead and eRank help too!)

I particularly noticed that early organic interactions like likes, saves, and carts signal listing quality to Etsy, naturally boosting visibility in search results. For me personally, I’ve become convinced that gaining organic traction first helps Etsy better categorize and recommend your products.

That’s how successful shops actually grow. They build organic SEO strength as a foundation before adding paid marketing on top. It’s similar to making friends at a new school. You first need to show who you are and what you’re about before hosting a big party and inviting everyone over.

When It’s Actually Smart to Invest in Etsy Ads

I can’t stress enough why timing matters with ads. If you’re feeling impatient about being invisible, resist the urge to advertise prematurely.

I recently discovered that ads work best when your listings already show positive performance indicators:

Healthy click-through rates from organic search
Frequent saves and add-to-carts from unpaid traffic
At least a few authentic reviews from satisfied customers

My research shows the best-performing ads are almost always for listings that were already selling consistently without advertising. This isn’t coincidental. Etsy’s advertising system leverages data from organic performance to optimize ad placement.

Later, when your shop already resonates with buyers, ads can help you reach a wider audience more quickly. It’s like having already proven that people enjoy your cooking before deciding to open a restaurant. You’re building on success rather than hoping for a miracle.

SEO and Etsy Ads Beginner Checklist

I developed this checklist because I was frustrated by wasting money on unoptimized listings. Before launching ads, make sure you’ve covered these essentials:

Create 5-10 fully optimized listings with strong SEO keywords strategically placed in titles, tags, and descriptions
Develop high-quality product photos (at least 5-7 per listing) with clear, inviting descriptions
Select the correct search categorization for each product
Look for signs of organic visits, saves, or carts to your listings
Complete all shop policies and create an engaging About section
Aim for at least 1-2 customer reviews to build buyer trust
Identify which products are naturally gaining traction to prioritize for advertising

I genuinely feel that taking time with this checklist before launching ads can save you significant money and frustration. After all, would you rather spend $50 testing unoptimized listings or invest that same money in listings that are already showing promise?

SEO Fundamentals Before Running Ads

I absolutely love diving deep into keyword research because it forms the backbone of successful Etsy SEO. I don’t just guess what people might be searching for – I use actual data to guide my decisions.

First and foremost, I primarily focus on finding long-tail keywords (3-5 word phrases) that specifically describe products. For instance, instead of just “handmade necklace,” I’d use “boho turquoise pendant necklace.”

Additionally, I strategically place these keywords in listing titles, prioritizing the most important ones at the beginning. Furthermore, I incorporate keywords naturally throughout descriptions, especially in the first few sentences.

I was skeptical at first, but I’ve found that utilizing all 13 available tags with relevant keywords, including variations and synonyms, dramatically expands potential visibility.

Beyond keywords, I’ve learned that crystal clear, well-lit photos showing items from multiple angles are non-negotiable. It’s best to include lifestyle images showing products in use, as these help buyers envision owning items. It’s like the difference between seeing a cake recipe and actually watching someone enjoy eating the cake. One sells the experience much better!

Starting Small with Etsy Ads

When you finally decide to test Etsy ads, you start with a modest daily budget. Just $3-5 per day for initial testing. This allowed you to gather data without risking too much.

As a result, you carefully selecte your 3-5 best-performing listings for your first campaign. Items that already converted well organically.

Subsequently, you closely monitor advertising statistics, paying particular attention to:

Click-through rate (CTR)
Cost per click (CPC)
Conversion rate from ad clicks
Return on ad spend (ROAS)

After collecting about two weeks of data, you can evaluate performance and make data-driven decisions about increasing budget, adding more listings, or pausing underperforming ads. It’s similar to testing the water before diving in. You want to know what you’re getting into before committing fully.

The Patient Path to Success

I seriously can’t overstate why patience pays off with Etsy. Before diving into ads, take time to build a rock-solid SEO foundation. By optimizing listings first, nurturing organic growth, and strategically deciding when to invest in ads, you set yourself up for sustainable success.

This patient approach leads to more sustainable results and a healthier return on investment. By resisting the urge to advertise prematurely, you’ll develop a deeper understanding of your market, refine your offerings based on real customer feedback, and create a more resilient business.

In conclusion, the most successful sellers understand that paid advertising works best as part of a comprehensive marketing strategy, not as a substitute for solid SEO practices. I firmly believe that when your listings are properly optimized and already gaining organic traction, ads can serve as a powerful catalyst for accelerated growth. Remember, Rome wasn’t built in a day, and neither is a successful Etsy shop!